Him? Or HIM?! So confused, please help! :(?

So there are these two guys. The first one isn't super hot or anything, but he's super sweet. The OTHER guy is a looker, not sweet, but hilarious. I've been texting the first one for months now, and we're always nervous around each other; I'm 95% sure he like me. BUUUT, I've been thinking more about buy #2 lately. Thinking about his smile (melts my heart) and his great personality. I'm just really confused, and don't want to end up hurting the first guy. WHAT SHOULD I DO?!